Live Help
Live Help

Home Builder has registered a complaint in opposition of Water District claiming water provided by the district produces leaks throughout piping.

Santa Ana, CA: Several homebuilders already have reported claims with Orange County Superior Court proclaiming water furnished by the Southern County water districts can be corroding plumbing, creating leaks which require thousands of dollars for copper repiping repair and installation.

Shapell Industries registered their grievance Nov 2, claiming the water transported through the Moulton Niguel Water District for Shapell residences within more than one Laguna Niguel communities; San Joaquin Hills in addition to Hillcrest were treated with chloramine, a chemical disinfectant in which Shapell claimed is known to cause pinhole leaks in the pipes of homeowners throughout the area.

The claim states Shapell “will be forced to correct and change out plumbing for at least 600 households” in those neighborhoods. The objection could not designate the amount of houses that in some way have leaking. The builder is attempting to get more than $5 million in monetary damages, citing product liability, negligence, private nuisance and infraction of service contract.

MNWD facilitates services to 57,000 residences and businesses in Laguna Niguel, Aliso Viejo, Laguna Hills and parts of Mission Viejo and San Juan Capistrano.

“The only people complaining about a lot of these leaks are in homes built by Shapell in these two districts,” MNWD general manager Bob Gumerman said in his email. “If the water was to blame, the particular issue would certainly be wide-spread.”

Gumerman accentuated the district’s water hits or is greater than federal and state water-quality specifications and acceptable for bathing and other purposes. He said Shapell hasn’t provided facts about how MNWD’s water supply has contributed to pinhole pipe leaks in households. A number of voice messages to the attorneys which represent Shapell were not returned.

Gumerman said Moulton Niguel gets its water through the Metropolitan Water District of Southern California, who imports it out of the Colorado River as well as the State Water Project, a system of storage areas, reservoirs and lakes. Reported by its internet site, MWD works with chloramine, a mix of chlorine and ammonia, within the water treatment operation to destroy organisms in standard water.

MWD also delivers water within the Santa Margarita Water District, which services the remainder of Mission Viejo as well as Rancho Santa Margarita, Coto de Caza, Ladera Ranch and the Talega neighborhood in San Clemente. MWD and SMWD were named as defendants in a challenge registered Feb. 6 by Lennar Homes concerning pin-hole pipe leaks in aged pipes in the Verano area of Talega.

Lennar’s claim claims leaks in galvanized pipes in 55 Verano homes “are the major and/or secondary result of corrosive, excessive and/orincorrectly treated water” delivered by the districts. Lennar demands the districts to become held liable for the pipe leaks along with any expenses, damages or settlements suffered by Lennar by reason of the water leaks.

Newmeyer & Dillion lawyer Carol Zaist, which may be assisting Lennar, said the developer won’t discuss impending lawsuits.

Newmeyer & Dillion additionally represents homebuilder Standard Pacific, which in the complaint brought to the district in February located 72 family homes in Ladera Ranch and Talega where homeowners have complained of pinhole water leaks in piping and accompanied damage to property. The declaration was earlier refused by SMWD officers, and yet recent tests may overturn this principal ruling.

SMWD spokeswoman Michele Miller thought the district doesn’t modify or alter the water delivered by MWD, even noting SMWD water satisfies or goes beyond national water quality standards. As to the negative effects of drinking water treatment procedures, “the district feels there is no information to show how the region’s water is causing a corrosive influence on galvanized water pipes.”

Marc Edwards is a Virginia Tech civil and environmental engineering instructor as well as nationwide regarded expert on water pipe corrosion. An element of his work is actually to report what causes pipe failures and the way to deter them. He stated that a range of legal cases are appearing in California and he can possibly expect to become used as a possible expert witness.

“We’ve executed likely over a million dollars of investigating in the last nine years,” Edwards said. “We’ve confirmed that water chemistry and harsh water are fundamental contributors of pinhole pipe leaks.

“We fully grasp that other reasons are often times participating, such as substantial velocity in pipes and mediocre installation processes, thus each individual claim has to have reasonably detailed forensic examination to try to identify the possible underlying cause and treatment,” he included.

Edwards said similar regulations carried out to make water safer is likely to be resulting in pinhole leaks. Despite the fact disinfectants are necessary, far too much in most waters could perhaps be corrosive. He explained research on chloramine shows it on its own doesn’t always create corrosion in water pipes, although “it may be possible, even likely, that chloramine plus elements in the water might be extremely corrosive.”

Even though the Water District probably have positive intentions, corrections in order to satisfy requirements can be having unintentional implications, Edwards stated.

“There’s certainly very much that we understand,” he stated. “We’ve completely proven that this type of water is often a cause; not the only cause, but an underlying cause. However, there is a bunch many of us still do not know.”